Define the coordination objective
Selective coordination is an overcurrent protection objective: for a specified fault condition, the protective device closest to the fault should operate while upstream devices remain closed. The goal is to limit the outage to the affected portion of the system, not to promise uninterrupted service or protection against every possible event.
Start by identifying which loads and distribution paths must remain energized when a branch or feeder fault occurs. The responsible engineer should establish applicable code requirements, operating modes, and the portions of the system included in the coordination review. Requirements depend on the installation and authority having jurisdiction, so confirm them for the project.
Map devices from source to load
Coordination cannot be assessed from a panel schedule alone. Trace the source through utility service or on-site generation, service equipment, distribution switchboards or switchgear, transformers, feeders, and branch-circuit devices. Record each protective device in sequence, including devices on alternate sources, ties, and emergency or legally required systems where applicable.
For each path, identify which device is upstream and which is downstream relative to the source and load. A main breaker may protect a feeder device, while that feeder device protects downstream branches. Transfer switches, bus ties, and parallel sources can change current paths; include their normal and alternate configurations in the study scope.
Read time-current curves as a system
Time-current characteristic curves show the relationship between current and operating time for a protective device. Engineers compare curves for series devices to determine whether their response bands are separated over the relevant current range. Plotting should use consistent current bases and account for transformer ratios, device settings, and applicable tolerances.
A visual gap between curves is not, by itself, proof of coordination. Instantaneous pickup regions, short-time settings, clearing times, and manufacturer-specific trip characteristics can overlap or limit selectivity. The engineer must evaluate the device combination and fault-current range, using appropriate data for the exact protective devices being considered rather than generic curve shapes.
Account for available fault current
Available fault current affects how devices respond and whether their operating characteristics remain selective. Obtain utility contribution and source impedance where available, along with transformer kVA and impedance, conductor lengths and sizes, and motor or generator contributions. Include relevant system changes, such as a second transformer or closed bus tie, in the modeled cases.
Coordination must be checked at the locations and operating conditions required by the project. Maximum fault current can push devices into instantaneous or current-limiting regions; minimum fault current can affect clearing time and sensitivity. Confirm assumptions with the utility and responsible engineer, and identify missing data instead of treating estimates as verified values.
Choose and configure protective devices
Breaker frames, trip units, fuse classes, sensor ratings, and adjustable settings all influence coordination. Specify the intended device family and settings where known, while preserving required conductor and equipment protection. A setting that improves selectivity must still satisfy applicable protection criteria and remain within the equipment manufacturer's permitted adjustment range.
Equipment configuration matters because a switchboard or switchgear lineup must accommodate the selected protective devices, bus arrangement, feeder count, and connection requirements. UL 891 applies to low-voltage switchboards; UL 1558 applies to low-voltage metal-enclosed switchgear. Medium-voltage equipment is a separate design category, not covered by either low-voltage standard.
Specify the study and its deliverables
A coordination study typically documents the system model, protective-device data, assumptions, time-current curves, proposed settings, and findings for defined operating cases. Depending on scope and project requirements, engineers may also perform short-circuit and arc-flash analyses. Confirm the required standards, software or format, device data sources, and whether field verification is part of the work.
Ask the study provider to identify exceptions where selective coordination cannot be achieved across the required range, and to explain their impact and alternatives. A revised device, setting, or system arrangement may improve selectivity, but can affect protection, equipment selection, cost, and maintenance. The responsible engineer should review and approve final settings and recommendations.
Prepare an equipment-ready specification
A useful specification identifies system voltage, phase, frequency, available fault current, service and feeder ratings, grounding arrangement, enclosure and installation conditions, and source configuration. Add one-line diagrams, load schedules, conductor information, device schedules, and study requirements. For existing interfaces, provide verified connection dimensions and termination details rather than assuming compatibility.
For a quote on newly manufactured distribution equipment, state the required standards, lineup arrangement, protective-device preferences, coordination objectives, and any confirmed project-specific ratings or options. Our U.S.-built equipment uses American components, supports custom fabrication, and ships nationwide, including to Ohio. Confirm final design details with the engineer, utility, and AHJ as applicable.
Coordinate reviews before release
Study results and equipment design should be reconciled before drawings are released for construction. Check that specified devices match the modeled manufacturer, catalog family, trip unit, and settings, and that the physical lineup supports the required configuration. Substitutions during procurement can change curve characteristics, so route proposed changes for engineering review before acceptance.
At commissioning, qualified personnel should verify installed device identification and settings against approved documents and applicable procedures. Document deviations and update the model when system data or operating configurations change. Selective coordination is a design and verification process; the final outcome depends on actual equipment, system conditions, study assumptions, and the requirements adopted for the specific project.